Fight to save farmland from bulldozers

Save Crimple Valley

8:23am 17th August 2017
(Updated 2:34pm 17th August 2017)

Campaigners say there are just seven days left to save the Crimple Valley near Harrogate from development.

Council planners have earmarked fields behind St Robert's Church in Pannal as a potential site for 277 houses, along with 72 more next to Spring Lane.

Opponents to the plans claim that Harrogate Borough Council is not taking into account that some of the land lies on a floodplain, along with a lack of infrastructure, the strain it would put on local primary and secondary schools or the fact that more than 100 houses have already been approved for the former Dunlopillo site.

Howard West, Chairman of Pannal and Burn Bridge Parish Council, said: "With the consultation process closing on Friday 25 August, those opposed to the allocation of this land for further housing and employment use have only a week in which to save the Crimple Valley.

"And the overwhelming response from the PC's survey of residents' views is against these proposals.

"It is vital that those who are against these plans do register their concerns and comments. If not, then I truly fear the worst for these special landscape areas.

"Pannal is a village, yet my view is the Borough Council won't be satisfied until all the green spaces that separate us from Harrogate are concreted over.

"The fields nearest to the Crimple Beck are waterlogged for much of the year, yet the planners seem blinkered to this fact and are proposing houses are sited just 8m from the river!

"The lack of a suitable road network is another issue, yet it doesn't seem to have been considered.

"Traffic from this development would have to exit the site via a bridge over the River Crimple onto the A61, as access and egress within the village of Pannal would be totally impractical, unsafe and make congestion permanent rather than mainly at peak periods.

"It would appear the concept is to build houses on one side of the A61 and then provide employment for those residents across the road, although everyone knows it doesn't work like that anymore.

"The result is likely to be a phenomenal increase in traffic along the already congested A61 and add to the daily gridlock in Pannal and Burn Bridge villages.

"Nowhere in any of the plans does the documentation mention infrastructure, in particular road traffic density, which is already more than the roads were designed for or can cope with.

"While one appreciates the need to plan for further housing in the borough of Harrogate, the latest proposals are a knee-jerk reaction to an increase in projected numbers that at best are subjective and at worst just paying lip service to an assumed general increase.

"The figures are unproven, unsafe and therefore unsound. HBC has failed to investigate other alternatives in depth, but has opted either for development on land it bought in the 1950s or via landowners wanting to make a financial killing."

Harrogate Borough Council is also encouraging everyone to comment on the proposals before it makes any decisions.

Councillor Rebecca Burnett, Cabinet Member for Planning, said: "We have to be absolutely sure that we're getting it right. The council has to submit a Local Plan and go into the formal examination believing that we've put together something that is correct and opposition to it is quite helpful.

"It's a great democratic process to have checks and balances on what we're doing. Any criticism we will have to have a look and make sure that we're getting this right, so I'd encourage as many people as possible to respond to this consultation."

Comments on the proposals can be submitted on the Harrogate Borough Council planning portal at or by sending an e-mail (including your name and postal address) to

Pannal and Burn Bridge Parish Council has asked people to copy e-mails to

The consultation process ends at 4.30pm on Friday 25 August.

Share This Story

Delicious Submit this page to reddit
Suggested articles
First aid team at Rossett School in Harrogate

School raises money for life-saving kit in Starbeck

More than £1,000 will go towards installing a community defibrillator.


Defib hunt campaign will save more lives

Yorkshire Ambulance Service's campaign has helped to identify 41 life-saving defibrillators.

Most read
masham crash

Lucky escape after Masham crash

The driver and passenger of this car only suffered minor injuries after it came off the road on Friday night.


Cyclist hurt in Harrogate collision

His injuries are not thought to be serious.

Newer article

A-level students awarded more top marks

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: More than a quarter of students across Harrogate, Craven and Wharfedale have scored an A or A* in their results.

Older article

This Otley man is helping to save lives

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: He's making a huge difference to the market town.

Top articles

Police: No one else was involved in Gaia Pope's death

National: Police say Gaia Pope suffered no injuries to suggest anyone else was involved in her death.

Stampede kills 15 near popular tourist town in Morocco

World: At least 15 women were killed and another 10 people injured during a crush as food aid was distributed in a Moroccan village.

George Kruis and Mike Brown in England 35-man squad for Samoa

Sport: England head coach Eddie Jones has named a 35-man squad for the final game of their Old Mutual Wealth Series against Samoa, live on <em>Sky Sports Action</em>.

Jeffrey Tambor may quit Transparent amid harassment claims

Showbiz: Actor Jeffrey Tambor is considering quitting the Amazon series Transparent following two sexual harassment allegations made against him.

All this year's Christmas adverts - which is your favourite?

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: From Moz the Monster to Paddington Bear via some chocolate woodland creatures, we've put all this year's Christmas adverts in one place so you can choose a favourite.

Otley Business Summit declared a success

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: It discussed the future of the retail, light industrial and commercial economy in small towns.

LISTEN: Ripon author writes anti-bullying books for schools

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: Monica Gabb has started crowdfunding to get 1000 books into schools across North Yorkshire.

LISTEN: Harrogate fundraisers organise walk to mark World Prematurity Day

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: The group includes Sian Striskiene whose son was born 13 weeks prematurely.

Harrogate Christmas Market

Christmas: In full swing for 2017!

Experience Christmas At Thorp Perrow

Features: The kids will love meeting Santa!

Now open until 2am!

Food and Drink: "The happiest place in Harrogate"

LISTEN: Harrogate fundraisers organise walk to mark World Prematurity Day

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: The group includes Sian Striskiene whose son was born 13 weeks prematurely.

The 10 Rules of Regifting

Home & Garden: Save money, time and clutter

The Yorkshire floods: one year on

Special Reports: People affected by last year's downpours describe what has happened in the last 12 months

Tour de Yorkshire: LIVE BLOG

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: Follow all the action as 2017's Tour de Yorkshire hits the Stray FM area.

Tour de Yorkshire host venues confirmed

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: There'll be no re-run of this year's memorable Tour de France stage finish in Harrogate.

Christmas lights switch-ons near you

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: Find out where you can see the festive illuminations being turned on and when across Harrogate, Craven and Wharfedale.


Who's going to win I'm a Celebrity?