"It's outrageous": Harrogate teenager's fight to save her former school from "devastating" cuts

Zoe Pickering

Published by Lisa Darvill at 7:02am 6th November 2018.

Cuts to North Yorkshire's Pupil Referral Units have been branded "outrageous" and "devastating" by a former Harrogate pupil. 

17-year-old Zoe Pickering attended The Grove Academy, Harrogate's Pupil Referral Unit, when she was 14. 

The school, which is rated as Outstanding by Ofsted, takes children with complex behavioural and mental health problems who have been excluded from mainstream education.

It's facing a 83% reduction in funding, a loss of £800,000. Nine teachers will lose their jobs and several arts subjects will be lost.

North Yorkshire County Council is currently consulting on plans to change the way it funds provision for children and young people with additional needs. It means all of its Pupil Referral Units will receive a funding cut. 

Zoe, who's autistic, received a GCSE in Art during her two years at the school. She says she's worried about the impact losing arts subjects will have on students. 

She told Stray FM: 

"It made my self-esteem go up and I feel like I have the ability to do things, which a lot of the time I don't, especially before I got that qualification.

"I feel outraged because that was the most important part of my education. For a lot of people it would be more helpful than you can imagine." 

Zoe has launched a petition which so far has more than 1,000 signatures. She is also encouraging people to go to a public consultation event which is taking place tomorrow at The Cedar Court Hotel at midday.

You can hear more from Zoe here: 



Zoe's mum, Dr Rachael Pickering, became a parent governor at The Grove shortly after Zoe started there. A former prison GP, she's taken over as governor responsible for safeguarding. She says the cuts mean the school will only be able to offer English and Maths, which could be devastating for the students.

She said: 

"Children who are very hard to educate have often lost such a lot of confidence in these mainstream English and Maths classes that they don't want to touch it. As Zoe's story shows, it's Art or another creative or non-academic discipline that draws them back in."

Rachael is also raising concerns over student safety if the cuts go ahead. 

She added

"With a skeleton staff at The Grove, children with special needs, people with neurodevelopmental problems such as autism, people with complex mental health problems such as bipolar, they won't be able to be safely and properly supported.

"And we ignore these children at our peril. Society needs to plug the gap between people who are not bale to be educated in mainstream schools and people who risk dropping out of mainstream school altogether. 

"I happen to be a prison GP by profession. I've seen young adults arriving for their first prison term who talk about, as an early teenager, dropping out of mainstream school. They hang about on the streets and get no chance for a niche, bespoke education." 

A Stray FM investigation has revealed the number of students excluded from secondary schools in North Yorkshire has risen over the last three years. Since 2015, the figure has risen by nearly a third, going from 1,526 in 2015-16 to 1,978 in 2017-18. 

Rachael says they have noticed a rise in the number of children referred to The Grove. 

You can hear more from Rachael here: 


North Yorkshire County Council says it wants students to remain in mainstream education where possible, and is suggesting creating local partnerships made up of leaders from local primary and secondary schools and post-16 providers.

It says the plan was shaped by feedback from families, young people and partners.

Jane le Sage, North Yorkshire County Council’s assistant director for inclusion, said:

“Our vision is to deliver better outcomes for young people. We know that permanent exclusion has a negative impact in terms of educational outcomes and options in later life. So wherever possible we believe children should remain within mainstream education, in their local school with support to meet their needs.

“The proposals we are now consulting on are designed to help us to achieve that vision. We want to put spending power into the hands of local education leaders who best understand the needs in their area. We want to enable schools to utilise the resources available for alternative provision more flexibly to meet children’s needs in the best way, with the goal of reducing the number of young people permanently excluded and improving outcomes for them.

“That’s why we propose creating local partnerships made up of leaders from local primary and secondary schools and post-16 providers. The partnerships would work with the local authority, putting decision-making into the hands of local leaders. The partnerships would be allocated a sum of money and would have the flexibility to decide how to use that money to meet the needs of children and young people.

“Under our proposals, we would still provide enough places for the education of young people who have been permanently excluded from school. In Harrogate we intend to commission between 28 and 31 places per year and we would fund these places at £17,000 a place, rather than the current £19,000, which would bring us into line with national averages. Local partnerships could commission more provision from the pupil referral service if they felt that was the best option.

“As outlined in our strategic plan, we are reviewing the model of provision for young people who are unable to attend school due to medical conditions, including those with mental health needs, to strengthen the support they receive. We will ensure that this provision is available to those who need it and any proposed changes will be subject to a full public consultation in the near future.

“We recognise that our proposals may impact on the current model of alternative provision, but we are committed to working with mainstream and pupil referral service/alternative provision head teachers to agree a model which is fit for purpose into the future and focuses more on prevention rather than the need for permanent exclusion.”

North Yorkshire County Council's plans are currently out for consultation until 11th November.

The survey is on the county council website at www.northyorks.gov.uk/hnbconsult

You can find Zoe's petition at www.change.org/p/north-yorkshire-county-council-save-north-yorkshire-s-pupil-referral-service

Zoe also has a Facebook page, which you can find by searching Save the PRS. 

Email Icon

Sign up for exclusive news, competitions and offers.
Proper Local News updates from Stray FM

Newer article

Train services "not efficient enough" in Yorkshire

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: That's according to the Shadow Transport Secretary who was speaking in the region at the weekend.

Older article
Top articles

David Beckham follows ex-Manchester United teammates with 10% Salford City stake

National: Former England captain David Beckham has bought a 10% stake in Salford City, the non-league club have announced.

James Gandolfini's son Michael to play young Tony Soprano in prequel

World: James Gandolfini's son is to continue his legacy by playing a young Tony Soprano in the much anticipated prequel.

England's Owen Farrell confident of facing Ireland in Six Nations

Sport: Owen Farrell is confident he will be fit to play in England's opening Six Nations game against Ireland on February 2.

Model speaks out after eating pizza with chopsticks in 'racist' Dolce & Gabbana ad

Showbiz: A model who appeared in Dolce & Gabbana adverts which have been accused of racism has vowed to be a "better Chinese citizen".

Ilkley BID to set out how it'll spend £680,000 boosting business

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: The team behind the plans are launching their business plan next week.

"Pennies over pupils": Campaigners vow to continue fight as school cuts move forward

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: Senior county councillors have backed plans to cut funding for the county's pupil referral units.

Top racing jockeys to appear in North Yorkshire for Q&A session

Sport: Including professional Harry Bannister and Grand-National winner Daryl Jacob.

Behind The Scenes: Policing rural North Yorkshire

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: Stray FM went out on a shift with Craven's Neighbourhood Policing Team.

When will I have enough money to retire?

Business: And how to get a definitive answer.

Top Party Dresses for the Festive Season

Christmas: Local Blogger, the Harrogate Girl, picks the best frocks, gowns and outfits for the big Christmas parties of 2017.

The Yorkshire floods: one year on

Special Reports: People affected by last year's downpours describe what has happened in the last 12 months

"This will make my kids' Christmas"

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: Stray FM and Slingsby Gin offer a little light to a family who've had a tough year just before Christmas

Delve into deliciousness at Mother Shiptons Inn

Test pages: We sent Stray FM's James Stanley to try out the new menu at Mother Shipton's Inn Knaresborough.

Motorists warned of icy driving conditions

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: A weather warning of ice is in place across Harrogate, Craven and Wharfedale.

LIVE: Stage 4 of the Tour de Yorkshire

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: The Final stage of the Tour de Yorkshire is on today today, passing through Otley, Blubberhouses, Pateley Bridge and Skipton.

Tour de Yorkshire host venues confirmed

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: There'll be no re-run of this year's memorable Tour de France stage finish in Harrogate.


What kind of Vouchers would you like to buy in 2019?
Days out with the kids
Food & Drink
Hair cuts
Spa days
Beauty treatments
Hotel stays
Local Events
Group activities

Trending in Yorkshire

Santander to close 140 of its UK branches.

It includes Otley, Ripon, Skipton and Wetherby

Wintry weather arrives

We've gathered a collection of wintry snaps posted on Twitter.

Over £400,000 spent on CCTV cameras in Harrogate

The cameras are used to keep watch on roads and public spaces.

Motorists warned of icy driving conditions

A weather warning of ice is in place across Harrogate, Craven and Wharfedale.

North Yorkshire County Council to appeal to Treasury minister over lack of money

It's facing having to save more than £40m over the next three years

More news...