: Waiting for next track...

: Waiting for next track...

Planning inspector recommends 11 sites be deleted from Harrogate's local plan

Crescent Gardens Harrogate

Published by Local Democracy Reporter Lachlan Leeming at 5:22pm 15th March 2019.

The Government inspector tasked with scrutinising Harrogate Borough Council’s draft local plan has advised that 11 sites – containing more than 1000 proposed homes – be deleted from the blueprint, in his first round of feedback on the crucial document.

  • Harrogate council have been advised to remove 11 sites earmarked for housing developments from their draft local plan by a government planning inspector
  • The plan sets out a 20 year vision of where thousands of homes and businesses will be built
  • The inspector says proposed sites near Pannal, Pateley Bridge, Darley, Dacre Banks, Summerbridge, Borougbridge and Hampsthwaite should be deleted from the plan
  • This is largely down to the "significant harm" it would cause to the landscape and heritage (details below)

In a letter to the council’s executive officer of policy and place, inspector Richard Schofield stated the current plan includes “a large excess of housing allocations over and above the level required” to meet the borough’s Objectively Assessed Need (OAN) for housing.

He then states that sites recommended for deletion should be “read in the context of the plan’s considerable oversupply of housing”.

The largest site he advised be removed was PN19 – a block of agricultural land west of Leeds Road at Pannal, with a potential yield of 277 homes.

He wrote:

“Site PN19 is extensive.

“It is, in my view, markedly at odds with the size of Pannal and would be likely to result in a disproportionate addition to the village.

“It would advance the edge of Pannal to such an extent that, to all intents and purposes, the village would coalesce with Harrogate.”

He also found that development at fellow Pannal site PN17 “would be likely to cause significant landscape harm and harm to heritage assets”.

Developments at Pateley Bridge (P1, P5 and P10), Darley (DR14), Dacre Banks (DB5) and Summerbridge (SB1) were rejected largely due to the developments being within an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB).

Mr Schofield referred back to national planning policy, which he said made it clear that only “exceptional circumstances” would warrant development on AONB land.

He wrote:

“I am not persuaded that such a test could be passed in relation to development proposals for these sites, particularly given the, in some cases very significant, landscape harm likely to arise from them.”

He also stated the Pateley Bridge proposals were harmed by the reduction of bus services in the area since the plan was submitted.

He said:

“This calls into question the appropriateness of planning for major development on this route.”

Land at Aldborough Gate, Boroughbridge (B21) was rejected due to the “sensitivity and importance of the extensive area of Roman archaeology” which could more likely than not to be of national importance”.

Likewise, site HM9 at Hampsthwaite was in a “very prominent and exposed site on the edge of the AONB”.

He wrote:

“Development here would be likely to give rise to harm to landscape and heritage assets.”

Lastly, a site north of Swinton Road at Masham (M8) was rejected due to the potential of the development impacting on l’Anson mill opposite.

While conceding that mitigations could be put in place to allow for development, Mr Schofield said its proximity to the mill made it “seem prudent to me to take a precautionary approach at this stage”.

Mr Schofield said the removal of the developments from the plan was manageable given the surplus of housing budgeted for in the draft plan.

He wrote:

“Thus, given the level of housing supply and the, in many cases acknowledged, harm that is likely to arise from the above proposed allocations, I consider that to make the plan sound they should be deleted.

“The housing requirement could easily be met even with their removal and there has been no suggestion that five-year housing land supply would be compromised.”

The inspector also recommended the council carry out additional sustainability appraisals around potential sites for a new village.

He wrote:

“I consider that it would be sensible for the council to undertake additional work in this regard.

“In short, for it to assess broad locations around each of the proposed potential sites.

“I may comment further on the matter of the proposed new settlement in due course, if I deem it necessary in light of the additional work.”

Email Icon

Sign up for exclusive news, competitions and offers.
Proper Local News updates from Stray FM

Newer article
Top articles

International honours for Harrogate Town player

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: Nuno Pereira has been called up to represent his country.

Bank of England says 'nature' of Brexit will guide path for economy

National: Bank of England rate-setters have used their final meeting before the scheduled Brexit deadline to warn on the "nature" of the UK's departure from the EU.

Trump under fire over 'bizarre' John McCain funeral comments

World: Donald Trump has come under fire from his own party after unleashing a bizarre tirade against the late Republican Senator John McCain.

Real Madrid target West Ham's Felipe Anderson if Chelsea won't sell Eden Hazard

Sport: Real Madrid are planning a move for West Ham’s Felipe Anderson, should the Spanish side fail to land their number one transfer target Eden Hazard.

As Potter tour expands, Warwick Davis reflects on playing goblin banker

Showbiz: Warwick Davis says being a non-able bodied actor has pushed him to strive harder in his career.

Go GREEN with your business!

Business: Help the environment during Stray FM's Green Month!

Strictly Come Dancing stars visit North Yorkshire school

Education: And one student gets the dance of her life.

WATCH: 43 Minutes of Queen in the 70s

70s: The band's team have put together highlights of the their early career including some iconic performances.

Top Party Dresses for the Festive Season

Christmas: Local Blogger, the Harrogate Girl, picks the best frocks, gowns and outfits for the big Christmas parties of 2017.

"It's a fantastic place": Harrogate cancer centre celebrates major milestone

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: The Sir Robert Ogden Macmillan Centre at Harrogate District Hospital is marking its five year anniversary.

"This will make my kids' Christmas"

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: Stray FM and Slingsby Gin offer a little light to a family who've had a tough year just before Christmas

Delve into deliciousness at Mother Shiptons Inn

Test pages: We sent Stray FM's James Stanley to try out the new menu at Mother Shipton's Inn Knaresborough.

UPDATE: Driver cut free following crash on the A65

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: It's believed three cars have collided at Hellifield.

LIVE: Stage 4 of the Tour de Yorkshire

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: The Final stage of the Tour de Yorkshire is on today today, passing through Otley, Blubberhouses, Pateley Bridge and Skipton.

Tour de Yorkshire host venues confirmed

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: There'll be no re-run of this year's memorable Tour de France stage finish in Harrogate.

North Yorkshire districts among best places to live in UK

Harrogate, Craven & Wharfedale: Three parts of North Yorkshire have been named in the top ten places to live in the UK.


It's Green Month on Stray FM - how important is being green to you?

Trending in Yorkshire

International honours for Harrogate Town player

Nuno Pereira has been called up to represent his country.

Dangerous handheld phone use at the wheel "rockets" according to RAC

More than one in five motorists in Yorkshire admit to driving while using their phones.

New sites approved for housing developments around Harrogate

The council wants to build social housing.

Police appeal to find family of Ilkley man

Officers want to find the relatives of 74-year-old John Michael Evans, who died at his home.

More news...